Are You a Cat Person or a Dog Person – Or Is It Just a Myth?

Introduction

For as long as we can remember, people have been divided into two camps: cat people and dog people. The idea is so ingrained in our culture that it’s even influenced personality studies, stereotypes, and countless debates. But is there really such a thing as a “cat person” or a “dog person,” or is it just a myth?

The Psychology Behind the Labels

Various studies have suggested that people who prefer cats tend to be more independent, introspective, and enjoy quieter environments, while dog lovers are often seen as more social, energetic, and outgoing. A study by Carroll University in the US found that self-proclaimed cat people scored higher on intelligence tests and were more open to new experiences, while dog people tended to be more extroverted and agreeable.

However, while these studies may indicate trends, they don’t mean every cat lover is an introvert or that every dog lover is an extrovert. Personality is shaped by a multitude of factors, including upbringing, experiences, and even lifestyle preferences. Many people love both cats and dogs equally, which blurs the line between the two supposed categories.

Why Do People Identify as Cat or Dog People?

One reason for the distinction might be the fundamental differences between cats and dogs themselves. Dogs are generally more social and require more attention, while cats are more independent and tend to demand attention on their own terms. People may gravitate towards the pet that best aligns with their personality or lifestyle.

For instance, someone who works long hours and enjoys a quieter home environment might find a cat to be a better fit, while an active person who loves outdoor adventures may prefer the companionship of a dog.

Additionally, cultural influences play a role. In media and literature, dogs are often portrayed as loyal, lovable companions, while cats are depicted as mysterious, self-sufficient creatures. These portrayals might shape our perceptions of what it means to be a cat or dog person.

Can You Be Both?

Absolutely! Many animal lovers appreciate the unique qualities that both cats and dogs bring into our lives. Some households happily have both, and their owners wouldn’t dream of choosing one over the other. It all comes down to individual preference, lifestyle, and the kind of companionship one seeks in a pet.

At The Cat Butler, we obviously have a soft spot for our feline friends. Cats may have a reputation for being aloof, but we know just how affectionate, playful, and full of personality they can be. Whether you’re a cat person, a dog person, or both, what truly matters is the love and care you provide to your pets.

The Verdict?

While the “cat person vs. dog person” debate is fun, it’s not as black and white as it seems. People’s personalities are complex, and their pet preferences don’t always fit into neat categories. The most important thing is finding a pet that suits your lifestyle and brings joy to your life—whether they have whiskers or wagging tails.

Are you firmly in the cat camp, or do you have a soft spot for both? 

Sandra James

Owner & Founder

The Cat Butler was set up by Sandra James in recognition of the fact that a stay in a cattery can be unsettling for many cats and also their owners.